Generally, I only care for Bonnie Raitt's version of "I Can't Make You Love Me," and I sort of have a blind spot when it comes to men singing this song. I never believe them when they sing it. But I do believe and love Tank's version.
If you watched So You Think You Can Dance last night, the Vegas auditions, then you heard this song twice. I think dancers get to cheat a bit when they use exceptionally moving music for auditions. It's hard to tell whether it's the music moving the audience or the dancers, but SYTYCD hopefuls didn't chose this song. They pulled it from a hat or something by the producers' command.